Home » A Review of PlentyMoreFish: Pros and Cons

A Review of PlentyMoreFish: Pros and Cons

Are you ready to dive into the world of online dating? Have you heard about PlentyMoreFish, but don’t know what it’s all about? Well then, come along with me as I review this popular dating site and explore its features! Is it worth your time or just a fishy waste of energy? Let’s find out!


Well, if you’re looking for a dating site that’s worth your time and money, then PlentyMoreFish ain’t it. It’s like swimming in the shallow end of the pool – there just aren’t enough quality fish to choose from! Plus, their search feature is pretty weak so you’ll be stuck scrolling through profiles all day long with no real luck. All I can say is: save yourself some trouble and stay away from this one; trust me on this one!

PlentyMoreFish in 10 seconds

  • PlentyMoreFish is an online dating site.
  • It uses a unique matching algorithm to connect users with compatible matches.
  • The pricing options range from free to premium subscriptions.
  • Premium subscriptions cost $19.99 for one month, $44.97 for three months, and $79.94 for six months.
  • PlentyMoreFish also has an app available for download.
  • Its prices are competitive with other similar sites on the market.
  • The site offers a secure environment for its users with verified profiles and anti-scam protection.
  • It also provides an anonymous messaging system and detailed profile searching.
  • Users can even use a “Secret Admirer” feature to send anonymous messages to their crushes.
  • PlentyMoreFish also offers a “DateSafe” feature which allows users to verify their dates before meeting in person.

Pros & Cons

  • PlentyMoreFish offers a wide variety of search options to help you find your perfect match.
  • The site is easy to use and navigate, making it great for users of all ages.
  • It’s free to join, so there’s no risk in giving it a try!
  • Not many active users on the site.
  • Limited features for free members.
  • Some profiles appear to be fake or inactive.
  • Difficult to find potential matches in your area.
  • No way of verifying if someone is who they say they are online.

How we reviewed PlentyMoreFish

As an online dating expert, I and my team took a deep dive into PlentyMoreFish. We tested both the free and paid versions of this site to ensure that we had a full understanding of its features. To get an accurate picture, we sent messages to other users – in total over 200 messages were sent out across 10 days! We also checked for user safety by testing how easy it was for us as reviewers to create fake accounts with bogus information (it wasn’t!). We looked at different aspects such as ease-of-use on mobile devices; what kind of customer service they offered; whether or not their messaging system worked well etc. Our commitment went beyond just giving our opinion on PlentyMoreFish – something which sets us apart from other review sites who don’t offer such in-depth reviews – so you can be sure that when reading our review you are getting all the facts about this popular dating site!

User Profiles

If you’re looking for a dating site that offers more than just the same old profiles, PlentyMoreFish is definitely not it. This online platform has some serious flaws when it comes to its user profiles.

For starters, all of the profile information is public and anyone can view them without signing up or creating an account. That means any creepers out there could be lurking around your profile if they wanted to – yikes! Plus, there isn’t much room for customization either; you’re stuck with what’s given on their template and can’t set a custom bio like other sites offer. Location info in each profile also cannot be hidden so people know exactly where you live – which makes me feel super uncomfortable about using this service at all! And speaking of location info…there doesn’t seem to be any indication as far as distance between users goes either so good luck trying to find someone close by who actually meets your criteria (if that even exists).

On top of all these issues with privacy settings and personalization options, I found quite a few fake accounts while testing out PlentyMoreFish too – no thanks! Not only did those take away from my time spent searching through actual real-life prospects but they also took away from potential matches since most were blocked after being flagged multiple times anyway…which kind of defeats the purpose altogether don’t ya think? Even worse yet was finding out how little benefits come along with having a premium subscription here compared to other similar sites; really nothing worth mentioning whatsoever besides maybe getting access to extra search filters every now & then…but honestly who cares about those?!

All in all I wouldn’t recommend wasting your time or money on this one folks; unless fish puns are totally up your alley then stick somewhere else because trust me when I say ‘you won’t get hooked’ here anytime soon haha

Signing up

Registering on PlentyMoreFish is a piece of cake. You’ll be ready to start fishing for love in no time! The website requires you to be at least 18 years old, so if you’re not quite there yet, it’s best that you wait until the right age before diving into this pool of potential partners. Fortunately, signing up won’t cost anything – it’s free as can be!

First things first: head over to their homepage and click "Sign Up" near the top-right corner. From here they’ll ask for your email address and password; fill those out with whatever works best for ya (just make sure both are secure!). Once that’s done they’ll want some basic info like gender identity and location – easy peasy stuff like that shouldn’t take more than two minutes or so. After all these boxes have been checked off comes the fun part: creating your profile page where everyone else will get an idea about who exactly YOU are when browsing through profiles online. They offer plenty of options from uploading pictures/videos (if desired) along with other tidbits such as interests & hobbies which should give people an insight into what makes YOU tick without having met face-to-face just yet! Lastly after filling out everything needed – voila –you’ve officially become a member on PlentyMoreFish! Now go forth bravely onto this dating site journey by searching around using filters tailored specifically towards YOUR needs…or maybe even try something new? Who knows what could happen?!

  • To register on PlentyMoreFish, you will need:
  • A valid email address
  • A username and password
  • Your gender and the gender of the people you are looking to meet
  • Your age
  • Your location (city/state)
  • An optional profile photo

Design & Usability

When it comes to PlentyMoreFish, the design and usability of this dating site leave a lot to be desired. The colors are drab and unappealing – think washed out blues, grays, and whites that make you want to take a nap instead of search for love.

The navigation isn’t any better either; there’s no intuitive way around the website so users can easily get lost in its depths or miss important features altogether. Even when I was able to find what I needed eventually (after much searching), it still felt like an uphill battle! It doesn’t help that some parts feel outdated with their clunky buttons or tiny text boxes where you have trouble typing anything more than one word at once. It also seems like if you pay for a subscription on PlentyMoreFish then maybe things would improve slightly but not by much; sure they might give your UI an upgrade here-and-there but overall nothing major changes from free memberships versus paid ones which is quite disappointing considering how expensive those subscriptions are!

Overall, using PlentyMoreFish feels about as fun as pulling teeth – slow going with little reward in sight! If they could spruce up their visuals while making navigating easier then maybe we’d see more people sticking around longer…but until then? Yikes!

Mobile App

Well, folks, it looks like the verdict is in on whether PlentyMoreFish has a mobile app. Unfortunately for those of us who love to stay connected while out and about, there’s no such thing as an official PlentyMoreFish app. Bummer! But why? Well that’s what we all want to know right? It could be due to the fact that they already have a well-established website with lots of users so creating an additional platform may not seem worth their time or money investment at this point in time. It also might be because developing native apps can take quite some effort and resources which many companies are simply unable or unwilling to commit too. That being said though if you really need your online dating fix when away from home then don’t despair just yet – plenty more fish (see what I did there?) still exist outside of PMF’s waters – check out any number of other dating sites’ apps instead! Now although having access through our phones would certainly make life easier for many singles looking for love on the go – let’s face it; nothing beats good old fashioned face-to-face interaction when trying find someone special! So maybe this lack of mobility isn’t necessarily a bad thing after all…


When it comes to PlentyMoreFish, the old adage "you get what you pay for" definitely applies. The website isn’t free – in fact, there are several tiers of paid subscriptions available ranging from $9.99/month up to a whopping $44.99/month! While that might seem like a lot for an online dating site, they do offer some nice perks with their higher-tier plans such as access to exclusive events and increased profile visibility on search results pages.

That said, when compared against other sites offering similar services at competitive prices (eek!), it’s clear that PlentyMoreFish is way out of line here – especially considering how little bang you’re getting for your buck! It may be worth taking advantage of one month’s subscription if you really want access to those extra features but otherwise I’d suggest steering well clear unless your wallet can handle the hit…

Plan Price Features
Free $0 Create a profile, browse profiles, send winks, add favorites, view photos, search for matches
Plus $14.99/month All features of Free plan plus unlimited messaging, see who viewed your profile, use advanced search
Premium $24.99/month All features of Plus plan plus highlighted profile in searches, message read receipts, access to exclusive events

Similar Sites

Some alternatives to PlentyMoreFish include Match.com, eHarmony, and OkCupid which are all popular online dating sites that offer a variety of features for users looking for meaningful relationships.

  • Match.com
  • eHarmony
  • Plenty of Fish
  • OKCupid
  • Tinder

Best for

  • Best for those looking to find a long-term relationship.
  • Best for singles who are seeking companionship and friendship.
  • Best for people who want to explore different types of relationships, such as polyamory or open relationships.


1. How can I contact PlentyMoreFish?

You can contact PlentyMoreFish, but I wouldn’t recommend it. It’s a dating site that doesn’t take customer service seriously and they don’t respond to inquiries in a timely manner. Plus their support team is unhelpful and not knowledgeable about the product or services they offer.

2. What are PlentyMoreFish alternatives?

PlentyMoreFish is a total waste of time, there are much better alternatives out there. I’d suggest checking out other dating sites like Match or eHarmony if you’re looking for something more reliable and trustworthy. Don’t bother with PlentyMoreFish – it’s not worth your time!

3. Can you send messages for free on PlentyMoreFish?

No, you can’t send messages for free on PlentyMoreFish. It’s a pay-to-play kind of site and they make sure to nickel and dime you every step of the way. Not worth it in my opinion!

4. How to cancel subscription on PlentyMoreFish?

It’s really not that easy to cancel your subscription on PlentyMoreFish. You have to go through a lot of steps and it takes forever. Plus, you don’t even get an email confirmation when the cancellation is complete so there’s no way of knowing if it actually went through or not!

Paul Sanders

Paul Sanders is an online dating expert who has dedicated his life to helping people find love. He holds a degree in Psychology from the University of California, Berkeley and he also studied Human Resources at Stanford University. Paul's passion for finding true connection between two people began when he was young - as soon as he could understand relationships, Paul knew that it was something special and worth exploring further. He started writing reviews on various dating sites and apps shortly after graduating college with the intention of giving advice to those looking for their perfect match or just wanting some tips on how to navigate through the digital world of romance. His articles have been featured in publications such as The New York Times, Cosmopolitan Magazine, GQ Magazine and more! With over 10 years experience under his belt now (and counting!), there’s no one better than him when it comes down to navigating through all things related to online dating today – whether you're single or already taken! Paul believes that everyone deserves a chance at happiness; this drives him every day towards making sure each person finds what they are looking for out there in cyberspace: companionship, understanding & ultimately love!

Post navigation

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *